
Concepts of Arthur: Early Arthurian Tradition and the Origins of the Legend |
|
| In Search of England: Journeys into the English Past by Michael Wood, 352 pages. Wood is, as Amazon.com says, a "popular television historian". He is also, however, a remarkably perceptive critic and the author of academic articles. His latest book includes thoughtful chapters on Robin Hood, King Alfred and Glastonbury/Avalon, amongst other topics. It also includes a fascinating piece on King Arthur, which goes beyond his earlier work on the topic and in which he seems to independently reach almost identical conclusions to Dr Padel with regards to the battle of Badon. All in all a superb book which manages to be both entertaining and scholarly. | |
| An Age of Tyrants: Britain and the Britons, A.D. 400-600 by Christopher Snyder, 320 pages. A superb, comprehensive and up-to-date analysis of recent historical and archaeological research into post-Roman/'Arthurian' Britain, this is an absolutely essential volume for anyone who has even the slightest interest in this topic. The discussion of the use of terms such as tyranni is particularly illuminating, whilst the survey of archaeological work will be especially valuable to those without access to either a university library or Dr Snyder's earlier B.A.R. volume. The author is a noted expert on the period and a professor at Marymount University, and his text is refreshingly free from the inaccuracies and flawed methodologies (particularly with regards to written sources) which mar many 'amateur' books on 'Arthurian period' Britain. Indispensable. | |
| The Mabinogi, and Other Medieval Welsh Tales, translated by Patrick Ford, 205 pages. Perhaps the most important witness to the Celtic Arthurian legend is the substantial (and endlessly fascinating) prose tale Culhwch ac Olwen, which may, in its present form, date from as early as the 10th-century and is certainly the oldest Arthurian tale in existence. In this volume Professor Ford provides both a scholarly and elegant translation of the text of Culhwch ac Olwen and also a highly valuable discussion of the tale itself. For these alone the book is worth its cover price. In addition to this, however, there are also to be found in this volume superb translations and discussions of the famed Four Branches of the Mabinogi, which are perhaps our best window into Welsh pre-Christian mythology, as well as the texts of the Gwion Bach/Taliesin legend and the only reliable full translation available of the highly archaic and important 'Arthurian' poem Kat Godeu. | |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| The World of King Arthur by Christopher Snyder, 192 pages. A recent and thorough survey of the Arthurian legend from post-Roman period to the present, by the author of the highly recommended An Age of Tyrants. This is a beautifully illustrated volume which covers all the major arguments and texts relating to Arthur, from his possible historicity in the 5th-century (and what he would have been like if he did exist then) to Geoffrey of Monmouth, Chrétien de Troyes, Malory, Wagner and modern Hollywood versions of the legends. This is an amazing resource, especially for those relatively new to the Arthurian legend, which manages to treat in a measured, readable and reliable fashion the entire 1500 year stretch of the Arthurian legend. | |
|
The Arthur of the English: The
Arthurian Legend in Medieval English Life and Literature
edited by W.R.J. Barron. This enormously important
volume brings some of the top Arthurian scholars together in order to
fully investigate all aspects of the Arthurian legend in the English
language and culture up to the end of the middle ages. This is the sister
volume to the indispensable
|
| The Age of Arthur : A History of the British Isles from 350 to 650 by John Morris, 665 pages. An incredibly influential book amongst Arthurian enthusiasts, this is a brilliant and highly readable account of 'Dark Age' Britain and the place of Arthur within it, as 'reconstructed' by the late Dr Morris. Unfortunately the methodology used in this 'reconstruction' is completely wrongheaded and this book destroyed Morris' academic reputation. Nevertheless it is undeniably a great work by a scholar who was fully immersed in his source material. Those new to Arthurian studies will find it endlessly fascinating and stimulating. Those who are more familiar with the primary sources and approaches of the period will probably be unable to accept his main conclusions and 'reconstructions' but will find, as Professor Campbell has, that the innumerable individual observations, comments and analyses away from his main thread of argument are invaluable and insightful. | |
| The Quest for Arthur's Britain edited by Geoffrey Ashe, 252 pages. A classic work of Arthuriana, this book should be on the bookshelves of anyone interested in the Arthurian legend. Essentially the book is a collection of essays on Arthurian history, archaeology and legends by illustrious and respected authors such as Geoffrey Ashe himself (contributing several pieces on the legend), Leslie Alcock (on his famous Cadbury-Camelot excavations), C.A. Ralegh Radford (on his work at Tintagel and Glastonbury Abbey), and Philip Rahtz (on Glastonbury Tor). Although the archaeological parts are now somewhat out of date (it was first published in 1968; more recent work - often by the same authors - is discussed in Snyder's book, recommended above) it is still a justly famous and very entertaining work which was extremely influential in its time, and the essays by Ashe are also still well worth reading. As the source of much subsequent discussion of the Arthurian legend it is highly important work and it was a prime mover in establishing the notion (pursued in the 1970s by both Morris -- in The Age of Arthur, recommended above -- and Alcock) that post-Roman Britain should be seen as 'Arthurian Britain'. | |
| The Discovery of King Arthur by Geoffrey Ashe, 224 pages. A passionate and interesting discussion of the Arthurian legend by Geoffrey Ashe, outlining his theory that Arthur can be identified with a king named Riot(h)amus from the 5th-century. This is perhaps the most plausible and successful of all the attempts to identify a real King Arthur, and as such is immensely popular with many Arthurian enthusiasts and scholars (though, as mentioned elsewhere on the 'Arthurian Resources' website, those who study the early Arthurian legend and its sources are considerably less enthusiastic about the explanatory power of this theory, though the parallels Ashe identifies are not denied). | |
| From Scythia to Camelot: A Radical Reassessment of the Legends of King Arthur, the Knights of the Round Table, and the Holy Grail by C. Scott Littleton and Linda A. Malcor, 401 pages. 'From Scythia to Camelot' is a challenging book by two academic folklorists. Its central thesis is that the Arthurian legend is not in fact British in origin but rather that it belongs to the steppes of southern Russia and the Ukraine, the 'core' elements of the legend being brought to Britain (it is claimed) by Scythian cavalry under the command of Lucius Artorius Castus in the 2nd-century AD. This notion has not been generally accepted (to say the least) and it fails to convince for a number of reasons (not simply because of a wish to preserve scholarly orthodoxy, as some have claimed; I have offered some criticism in 'The Historicity and Historicisation of Arthur). Nevertheless, despite its flaws, it is an interesting and stimulating piece which deserves to be read, particularly as Joel Schumacher ('Falling Down', 'Tigerland', 'Batman and Robin') is apparently making a 'historical' Arthurian movie based around this theory. | |
|
The Historic King Arthur: Authenticating the Celtic Hero of Post-Roman Britain by Frank D. Reno. Another 'historical Arthur' theory, this time identifying Arthur with the 5th-century Ambrosius Aurelianus. Though it suffers from many of the faults commonly found in such amateur investigations into the 'historical' Arthur, this is interesting because the candidate identified is in many ways the most plausible of all those that have been proposed in recent years. As I suggest in 'The Historicity and Historicisation of Arthur', it is not unreasonable to see the 'historical Arthur' of Historia Brittonum chapter 56 as being based upon the deeds of Ambrosius Aurelianus (as recorded by Gildas) and thus I would argue that, to some extent, Ambrosius should indeed be seen as the 'historical Arthur'. This is an intriguing coincidence and it alone makes this book more worthy of a look than many of the others of this type available. |
| The Arthurian Handbook edited by Norris Lacy, 400 pages. In many ways this volume covers similar ground to Snyder's The World of King Arthur, insofar as it investigates the entirety of the Arthurian legend from its supposed 5th-century origins to Monty Python and the Holy Grail. It is, however, a collaborative work which covers its chosen topics in far greater detail than Snyder does, with chapters by noted Arthurian experts such as Professor Lacy and Geoffrey Ashe. As a critical survey of Arthurian archaeology, history, legend, tournaments, literature, film and stage it succeeds admirably and is a valuable reference work and companion to Professor Lacy's superb The New Arthurian Encyclopedia . | |
| Celtic Myth and Arthurian Romance by Roger Sherman Loomis, 371 pages. A classic and very readable work of Arthurian scholarship, by one of the leading researchers of the early to mid 20th-century. Whilst Loomis' conclusions, which focus on the influence of Celtic nature mythology on medieval Arthurian Romances, are now often challenged, they shouldn't be ignored and still repay close reading (especially given recent theories, such as those in From Scythia to Camelot, which attempt to discredit the notion of any Celtic influence on Arthurian Romance). |
| The Celtic Heroic Age. Literary Sources for Ancient Celtic Europe and Early Ireland and Wales edited by John Koch and John Carey, 425 pages. This volume by two respected Celtic scholars is an absolutely superb sourcebook. Essentially it does exactly what it says in the title. It provides introductions to and translations of nearly every single important early Celtic literary source, and as such is invaluable to anyone concerned with this material or the early Celts. It is divided into three sections. The first deals with Ancient Celtic Europe, and includes Gallic inscriptions and classical accounts; the second deals with Early Irish and Hiberno-Latin Sources, such as the Book of Invasions and the Ulster Cycle; and the third deals with Brittonic Sources. The latter section is the most interesting, particularly from the Arthurian perspective. It includes Professor Koch's intriguing reconstruction and translation of Y Gododdin; a translation of parts of the Historia Brittonum (including chapter 56, the earliest source to have an unequivocally historical concept of Arthur); good translations of the important Arthurian poems of Pa gur yv y porthaur? and Preideu Annwfyn; and translations of Marwnad Cynddylan (which dates from the mid 7th-century and contains a reference to Arthur as a peerless warrior) and a Breton foundation legend which is highly illuminating with regards to the legendary Taliesin. | |
| The Mabinogion edited by Gwyn Jones and Thomas Jones. The Mabinogion has been the most revered and studied collection of Welsh native literature ever since Lady Charlotte Guest's pioneering version in the 19th-century. This version replaced Guest's translation in the Everyman Library and, whilst lacking some of the literary merits of its predecessor, it is by far the most accurate and reliable translation available and is the only version which is used for serious scholarly research. Included in this collection are two wholly native Arthurian tales, Culhwch ac Olwen (the earliest Arthurian tale in existence) and Breuddwyd Rhonabwy (The Dream of Rhonabwy), as well as the Three Arthurian Romances (which seem to be related to but not derivative of Chrétien de Troyes' French Romances) and the famed Four Branches of the Mabinogi (which give the volume its name). | |
| History of the Kings of Britain by Geoffrey of Monmouth. Geoffrey of Monmouth's Historia Regum Britanniae ('History of the Kings of Britain') is the single most important text of the Arthurian legend. It was this text that started the fundamental transformation of the Arthurian legend from a tale of local British folklore into the internationally adored and popular 'Matter of Britain' which dominated the Middle Ages. Though the surviving bits and pieces of the early Welsh Arthurian legend (such as Culhwch ac Olwen) are now seen as pre-dating Geoffrey's magnum opus, this cannot lessen the importance of this text. He may not have invented Arthur but he is ultimately responsible for the medieval and modern image of Arthur and the fact that we still tell stories of him. This is not, however, the only reason why the History of the Kings of Britain deserves to be read by all who are interested in Arthuriana. It is also used by many, many authors as the basis of their (mutually exclusive) theories as to the identity of the 'historical Arthur'. Most important of all, however, is that the book stands on its own as an enjoyable and fascinating read. | |
| Arthurian Romances by Chrétien de Troyes, 521 pages. Whilst Geoffrey of Monmouth made Arthur internationally famous, it was the Romances of Chrétien de Troyes and those who followed him that gave us many of the familiar characters and stories of the Arthurian legend. This collection of Chrétien's works includes the first appearances of both Lancelot and the Grail. Worth reading both for their importance to the development of the Arthurian legend and for their own inherent literary merits. | |
| Le Morte D'Arthur by Sir Thomas Malory, 976 pages, $11.97. If Geoffrey of Monmouth's 'History of the Kings of Britain' is the ultimate source for the popularity of the Arthurian legend, and the French Romances introduced many of the familiar characters and stories, then Malory's Le Morte D'Arthur is the medium through which the medieval 'Matter of Britain' is transmitted to the modern era. This is the definitive version of the Arthurian legend and it underlies most modern treatments of the legend. Quite simply, it is a masterpiece to be placed alongside J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings as one of the greatest works of fantasy of all time. | |
| Malory: Complete Works edited by Eugene Vinivar, 811 pages. This is not simply an alternative and more expensive version of the above book. Instead it is the critical version of the text in original Middle English, based not upon Caxton's printed text but rather upon the Winchester manuscript which is considered to underlie Caxton's printing and differs from it. Including an introduction, glossary and notes, this edition is essential to any scholarly research into Malory's Le Morte D'Arthur. |
| A Celtic Miscellany: Translations from the Celtic Languages translated by Kenneth Jackson, 343 pages. This book contains a wonderfully wide and varied selection of material in translation from both Irish and Welsh literature, chosen by the late Professor Jackson (one of the foremost experts in his field). Although the only specifically Arthurian text included in this volume is Culhwch ac Olwen, there is much here of value. Essential, especially for those whose interest in the Celtic materials extends beyond the relatively few Arthurian references to be found in them. | |
| Early Irish Myths and Sagas translated by Jeffrey Gantz. Although there is nothing specifically Arthurian in this volume it is, like Jackson's A Celtic Miscellany, well worth a look by anyone who has a general interest in Celtic literature beyond the Arthurian. | |
| Celtic Heritage: Ancient Tradition in Ireland and Wales by Alwyn Rees and Brinley Rees, 428 pages. An old but solid survey of Welsh and Irish mythological tales, this is far better than many modern popular efforts. The Arthurian sections are short but sweet, with parallels drawn between the Arthurian legend in Wales and that of Fionn in Ireland. However the main value in this book will, for many, lie in its role as an general introduction to (and summary of) Celtic mythologies and traditions. | |
|
|
| A Dictionary of Celtic
Mythology by James
MacKillop, 432 pages. Although not
overly scholarly, this is a comprehensive dictionary which includes a
number of interesting entries (both Arthurian and non-Arthurian). It is
perhaps the best of such efforts on the market, though it pales in
comparison with the
|
|
| Dictionary of Celtic Myth and Legend by Miranda J. Green, 240 pages. An alternative dictionary, this time compiled by noted Celticist Dr Miranda Green. | |
| The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles by Ronald Hutton. Dr Hutton's book is again only tangentially Arthurian, as its topic is pagan religious beliefs from the Palaeolithic to the present day. However, it does its job magnificently, managing both to be enormously entertaining and highly scholarly. The title may make it sound a little dry but rest assured the book is not, handling with considerable flair (and sensitivity) such controversial topics as the Mother Goddess hypothesis, ley lines, the survival of pagan beliefs in medieval Christianity, druidism, and modern Wicca. All in all an absolutely superb book - one of my favourites - and the only reason that it is not 'Highly Recommended' is because of the paucity of specifically Arthurian material! |